How to

Sell To Me

1.   Call me toll-free at 866-MD-COMIC


2.   We’ll discuss your collection and make an appointment to meet


3.   I will inspect your collection and give you a free appraisal


4.   I make you a cash offer on the spot

Colabuono booth web.jpg

Setting up for Wizard World Chicago Comic Con (2016)

Blackboard Transparent

What I Buy

Let me know what you have!  I buy it all!



I purchase most comics from 1934 to present.  Super-Heroes drive the market and are the most valuable category, but there are many Horror, Crime, Romance, Science Fiction, Archie and Teen Humor, Westerns, War, Jungle, Disney, and Funny Animal comics that are valuable too.



Comic Art

Whether you have original comic book or vintage comic strip art - I'm buying it all.  I'm actively seeking Peanuts and Marvel/DC Silver and Bronze age covers and splashes.



I'm buying vintage sports cards from 1900 to 1975 - baseball, football, basketball and hockey.  I'm also very interested in 1930 to 1970 non-sport trading cards like Superman, Batman, Horrors of War, Mars Attacks, Civil War News and many more.

And Much


Have any vintage Star Wars items? How about Nintendo or Atari video game cartridges? Old Toys?   Movie Posters? Have something old and you're not sure if it's valuable? Just contact me and describe what you have. I will identify it for you and appraise it at no charge.


         I was so lucky to find Gary!  After my husband passed away I didn't know where to turn.  A friend introduced me to someone who would buy his precious comic book collection.  I was offered $3,000.  Then another friend suggested I call Gary.  I was paid $35,000 for the collection!  Gary was a life saver!

Louise M. - Arlington Heights, IL

    When it was time to sell my collection I was so fortunate to have contacted Gary.  He took his time and patiently explained everything to my wife and me.   The net result was $125,000!   Gary is the man!

Bob and Claudia S. - Wilmette, IL

     I first met Gary 40 years ago. He was interested in buying my collection but told me since it had a lot of sentimental value to hold on to it.  He said I couldn't go wrong holding on to my comics.  Thanks to Gary's advice, when I decided to sell, I was paid $140,000!

Phil K. - Burlington, WI

        The first dealer I contacted offered me $30,000 for my collection.  I was impressed but thought I should get another offer so I contacted Gary.  Gary said that was way too low and offered $80,000!  Thank you, Gary!

Phil C. - Chicago, IL

      Gary is one of the most experienced, friendly and trustworthy guys I know.  Working with him was so easy.  He explained everything to me and made sure I understood each step.  Ours was a very complex deal but I was kept informed every step of the way.  If you have a very valuable collection make sure you contact Gary.  You'll get professional attention from start to finish as you maximize the return on your collection.

Steve L. - Kildeer, IL